Real options in management and organizational strategy. Real options in strategic management emerald insight. Real options theory in strategic management request pdf. Using real options in strategic decision making by chris walters and tim giles of london economics to maximize a firms value its managers must match internal capabilities to external opportunities. Three types of moves are especially relevant to implementing strategy under conditions of uncertainty. This article discusses some of the common pitfalls of strategic management and suggests some approaches to actualize strategies that make the firms market leaders. Chapter 18 covers the evaluation and selection of options. The analysis of strategic considerations, in a game theoretic sense, is still in its infancy and should be high in the realoption research agenda. Managing strategic investment in an uncertain world financial management association survey and synthesis. Real options can either be strategic or operational, as shown in figure 8. In the real world, game data is unavailable to players. In fact, possession of more information and larger strategic options has adverse effects on player utility aumann, 1976. Now we can draw a strategy in terms that are neither wholly strategic nor wholly.
This case is used to highlight some of the problems associated with using real options. Mit sloan school, 1972 1977 robert merton, fischer black, stewart myers had offices in a row on 2nd floor west of the sloan building e5227x option pricing methodology brought math rigor to valuation under uncertainty. Real options analysis has become a key management tool for many of todays businesses. Cox school of business, southern methodist university, p. Strategy, value and risk the real options approach citeseerx. Real options valuation, also often termed real options analysis, rov or roa applies option valuation techniques to capital budgeting decisions. The key premise of real options is the application of strategic decision making and flexibility in the face of future uncertainties. Real options theory in strategic management lenos trigeorgis1 and jeffrey j. Spotting real strategic options strategic options are a central in valuing new ventures option to expand option to delay option to abandon option to get into related businesses different approaches to valuing real options decision analytic approach binomial method black scholes model. The difficulty of developing customized models may explain, in part, the limited use of the real options approach in strategic analysis.
Real options theory has shown potential for analytical applications in strategic management, particularly to evaluate. Analysis of land value and strategic decisions in real estate development by chun kit so timothy so submitted to the. The distinction between strategic thinking, strategic management and strategic planning 45 strategy in actionquick strategic thinking in unfavourable circumstances45 strategy in actionsony the disruptive innovator 50 principles for the successful use of strategy 61 finding the right strategic mix of entrepreneurial creativity and. Managers actively cultivating a portfolio of opportunities are, in effect, working to push. Pdf real options in strategic management researchgate. Real options and strategic decisions by tom copeland and keith m. Proponents of this view stress the benefits for managerial flexibility and the value created from uncertainty when making strategic and operating decisions. By synthesizing and critiquing research on real options, we identify a number of important challenges as well as opportunities for rot if it is to enhance its impact on strategic management. Real options theory in strategic management trigeorgis 2017.
Yet without some changes, managerial patience with the complexity of a typical realoptions calculation may rapidly wear thin. A real options theory of strategic human resource management traditional hr architecture, which views different employee groups as a portfolio based on specificity and value, is static and insufficient under uncertainty. The investment opportunities can be considered as corporate real options, which are integral for corporate resource allocation and planning. In this paper we apply three types of uncertainty state, effect and response of milliken 1987, to real. The maximum of option values indicates which strategy should be chosen by the company. In a market with strategic competition, investment confers a greater capability to take advantage of. Pdf real options theory begins by drawing an analogy between real options and financial options. Introduction real options analysis is a research field that spreads across different academic and research disciplines such as finance, economics, operations research, engineering, supply chain management, strategic management, marketing, etc. Reuer2 1 department of accounting and finance, school of management and business, kings college london, university of cyprus, nicosia, cyprus 2 leeds school of business, university of. Real options theory in international business springerlink.
Too often, real options seems to need rocket science. The purpose of this research was to examine the potential for applying the concept of real options to the dod acquisition system. The discussion of the generation of strategic options is approached in three steps. Real options analysis and strategic decision making author. Resourcebased theory, dynamic capabilities, and real options a lthough early contributions to resourcebased theory and dynamic capabilities came from the discipline of economics e. It is an accurate method for estimating the value of corporate investments, and it can be effectively utilized in situations where management has flexibility in large capital budget decisions with high uncertainty. While optionpricing models are indeed a superior valuation toolthe usual use of the theorywe believe that real options can also provide a systematic framework serving as a strategic tool and that the real power of real options lies in this strategic application. Spotting real strategic options strategic options are a central in valuing new ventures option to expand option to delay option to abandon option to get into related businesses. Strategic management articles management study guide. Real options theory in strategic management, strategic.
We develop an alternative real options portfolio framework based on human. Payoff diagram for a put option as shown in figure 12, the net payoff of a put option remains negative and equivalent to the put price price paid to buy the option, as long as the under. Introduction in a recent section of the financial times, on october 4, 2010, while the biggest us auto manufacturer gm was announcing shutting down its opel plant in antwerp and laying off eight. As a result, users of real options models should understand the quantitative aspects of these models, and may often need to create a customized model for each situation. A real option is a choice made available with business investment opportunities, referred to as real because it typically references a tangible asset instead of financial. Flexibility in timing of decisions about the firms capabilities and. The real options approach is frequently advocated as an approach that offers a positive and radical reassessment of the value of risk and exploration. Jan 01, 2017 real options theory in strategic management real options theory in strategic management trigeorgis, lenos. By synthesizing and critiquing research on real options, we identify a number of important challenges as well as opportunities for rot.
Bowman deceased formerly at the wharton school, university of pennsylvania gary t. Managing strategic investment in an uncertain world financial management association survey and synthesis amram, martha, kulatilaka, nalin on. Strategic management plays a dynamic role in achieving success in todays business world. Managing a portfolio of strategic options is like growing a garden of tomatoes in an unpredictable climate. Borrowing from this logic, we explored the implications. These real options include the option to waittoinvest or the option to defer, the options to abandon and switch, and corporate table 1. Real options analysis in strategic decision making taylor. In this sense, they integrate these two aspects of your investment decision making in one tractable framework. Using real options in strategic decision making by chris walters and tim giles of london economics. This thesis sought to answer three research questions, how could real options be applied to the acquisition system, how could the. Strategic decision making using real options reasoning. Analysis of land value and strategic decisions in real estate development by chun kit so timothy so submitted to the program in real estate development in conjunction with. By synthesizing and critiquing research on real options, we identify a number of important challenges as well as opportunities for rot if it is to enhance its impact on strategic management and potentially develop into a theoretical pillar in the field.
By definition, a financial option gives its holder the right, but not the obligation, to buy or sell the underlying asset at a. Real options analysis allows the firm to determine how much this safety downside insurance or abandonment option is worth i. Real options analysis and strategic decision making edward h. Real options theory rot applies the heuristics and valuation models originally designed for financial securities to the domain of corporate investment decisions. Howe in the october 2001 issue ofstrategic finance,an article titled the realoptions approach to capital allocation presented the basics of realoptions analysis and showed why it is a widely used approach for valuing capital investments today. Real options analysis posits that the value of an option rises with increasing uncertainty in the underlying asset. Pindyck massachusetts institute of technology cambridge, ma 02142 robert pindyck mit lectures on real options part i august, 2008 1 44.
The real options approach is an extension of financial options theory. Real options theory in strategic management joseph t. A financial option is a derivative security whose value is derived from the worth and characteristics of another financial security, or the socalled underlying asset. Real options analysis an overview sciencedirect topics. As most managers do not use real options, but instead intuitively manage uncertainty, understanding the similarities and differences between decision maker perceptions of real options and real options theory is critical for improving the use of real options for risk management. To consider strategies as portfolios of related real options, this article exploits a framework. The last quarter century has witnessed substantial growth in applications of real options theory rot to international business ib research. We provide a strategic rationale for growth options under uncertainty and imperfect competition.
Reuer2 1 department of accounting and finance, school of management and business, kings college london, university of cyprus, nicosia, cyprus 2 leeds school of business, university of colorado, boulder, colorado, u. Real options analysis and strategic decision making authors. Teaching strategy, sms 2009 our ambitions at the time to change corporate decisionmaking i. But real options can distil your strategic thinking into focussing on a few, key dynamic processes, where a decisiontree would overflow the largest boardroom whiteboard. Real option valuation antoinette schoar mit sloan school of management 15. Real options analysis applies to sequential decisionmaking under uncertainty. Key topics themes illustrative strategy studies common real options and investment decisions investment opportunities as. Established in 1899 in turin, fiat is one of the oldest players in the automotive sector. Strategic management is a stream of decisions and actions, which leads to the development of an effective strategy to help achieve organizational objectives. The use of real options in strategic decision making. This is the fundamental premise for bayesian games, where each player i is of specific type. It also presents the views of scholars and practitioners regarding the incorporation and validity of real. Strategic decision making using real options reasoning under uncertainty what uncertainty stephen x. Real options theory in strategic management trigeorgis.
A real option itself, is the rightbut not the obligationto undertake certain business initiatives, such as deferring, abandoning, expanding, staging, or contracting a capital investment project. Real options theory begins by drawing an analogy between real options and financial options. Pdf real options analysis and strategic decision making. Applications of real options theory in strategic management. Strategic planning if done poorly results in more harm than good and this is the reason why the pitfalls of strategic planning and strategic management must be avoided. Real options analysis and strategic decision making. Teaching strategy, sms 2009 origin of the real options concept. Resourcebased theory, dynamic capabilities, and real options. In an increasingly uncertain world, real options have broad application as a management tool. Teaching real options strategic management society. Real options in strategic management 17 chapter by oriani examines the value of a speci. Strategic management process plays a dynamic role in organization. Introduction fiat is an iconic firm for better or for worse.
The essence of real options to understand the basis of the real options argument and the reasons for its allure, it is easiest to go back to risk assessment tool that we unveiled in chapter 6 decision trees. Real options theory in strategic management real options theory in strategic management trigeorgis, lenos. Real options reasoning ror is a conceptual approach to strategic investment that takes into. Real options thinking achieves this through its most basic contribution and most striking departure from the dictum of net present value. In this sense, the survey sought to contribute towards management knowledge in the organizational environment by clarifying what is the real understanding of management graduates on the themes of strategy and strategic management. Real options in strategic management 23 what challenges in other option investment stages e. We note that the assumptions incorporated in most standard option valuation models can conflict with the conclusions reached by strategic analysis.
393 1346 780 190 1387 275 335 1307 1191 392 1325 962 1069 424 3 224 490 1529 54 825 711 1541 394 108 928 403 1354 1056 289 881 966 1446 1358 437 1184 345 1323